Clarify trim-content principle: judge by user-path, not category

This commit is contained in:
2026-06-05 01:29:11 +03:00
parent 22f0556ef8
commit 3d38dd1411
+14 -6
View File
@@ -84,12 +84,20 @@ npm run format # Prettier
smaller bundle prove nothing about behavior: when a change touches what the user sees or
does, confirm it by exercising the feature, not by the compiler alone.
- **Trim content, not capability** — when narrowing a third-party import or build to cut
size, remove optional _content_ (languages, locales, themes, icon sets), never the
library's _features_. The smallest/lowest-level entry point is seldom the right one — it
often drops capabilities you meant to keep. Prefer the entry that excludes the unwanted
content while retaining behavior, and validate the behavior survived. (This bit us once:
importing Monaco's `editor.api` to drop unused languages also stripped every editor
feature — see `docs/architecture/08`.)
size, remove optional _content_, never the library's _features_. The smallest/lowest-level
entry point is seldom the right one — it often drops capabilities you meant to keep. Prefer
the entry that excludes the unwanted content while retaining behavior, and validate the
behavior survived. (This bit us once: importing Monaco's `editor.api` to drop unused
languages also stripped every editor feature — see `docs/architecture/08`.)
- The line isn't "content vs. capability" by category — it's **"does any real user path
depend on this?"** Safe to drop: data no user path exercises (a date formatter's unused
locale tables, an icon set you never render, themes you don't ship). _Not_ safe, even
though it looks like "content": **human-language coverage** — font script subsets,
translatable strings — which is capability the moment the app is meant to be usable in
that language. Treat dropping it like dropping a feature. (This bit us a second time:
trimming IBM Plex to the latin subsets dropped Cyrillic — capability for an
internationally-usable app. We ship every script subset and precache them for offline;
`unicode-range` means the browser only downloads what a glyph needs anyway.)
- **Spec is the contract** — when in doubt, read `docs/spec/`. If the spec is wrong or
silent, raise it; change the spec deliberately rather than drifting from it.
- **Core-first** — for each feature, build the pure `src/core/` logic with tests before UI.